Dissolution House Rules: Difference between revisions
imported>Wordman |
imported>Wordman |
||
(46 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
House rules for the [[campaign::Dissolution]] campaign. | House rules for the [[campaign::Dissolution]] campaign. | ||
== Basic Conversion == | |||
Since ''Ptolus'' is a 3.5 production, some basic [[Ptolus Pathfinder Conversion|conversion to ''Pathfinder'']] was required. | |||
== Classes == | |||
We add some unofficial classes: | |||
* [[Elemental Druid]] - a variation of the druid class, based on the four elements instead of animals and nature. | |||
* [[Arcane Hierophant (Pathfinder)|Arcane Hierophant]] - a divine/arcane prestige class lifted and mutated from 3.5. | |||
* [[Spellsword_(Pathfinder)|Spellsword]] - a gish prestige class lifted and (severely) mutated from 3.5. After using it for a while, we ditched it. | |||
== Experience == | |||
=== Progression === | |||
This is a really casual game that doesn't meet very often. So, we are using the "fast" experience table. | |||
=== Ding! === | |||
Along the same lines: we follow a more video game style of advancement. As soon as you gain enough XP to level, you ''immediately'' do so. In addition, you regain all hit points and gain and benefits as if having taken a full rest (spells refresh, etc.). There are campaigns where things like training and safe zones and such matter; this isn't one of them. | |||
== Players Roll Most Dice == | |||
In order to get the players more involved when it is the monster's turn, and to distribute (and often parallelise!) monster's actions, players roll most dice. Nothing changes when the PCs act; they roll just the same as always. When a monster attacks a PC, however, instead of the monster rolling an attack, the PC rolls defense. This works as follows (note, the number 22 looks a bit odd in the following formulas, but guarantees that the [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12ODzAkA_Jlfn6iJ43PJQvlQI0HUuz5CQfZGjThYzqhc/edit?usp=sharing probability of being hit] and so on remains unchanged): | |||
=== When monsters attack === | |||
The PC getting attacked makes a '''defense check''', rolling 1d20 + applicable AC against a DC of 22 + the attack modifier of the incoming attack. If the player meets or exceeds this DC, the attack misses. As with attack rolls, on the defense check a 1 always fails (meaning, you get hit) and a 20 always succeeds (meaning you defend, so the attack doesn't hurt you). | |||
On a roll of a natural 1, the attacking monster scores a threat (a possible critical hit). Make another defense check; if it again fails to avoid the attack, the opponent has scored a critical hit. If the monster has a greater critical range than usual, they threaten with a corresponding low defense check. For example, if the monster would threaten when rolling an 18-20 under normal rules, it would threaten if the defense check came up 1-3. | |||
=== When monsters need to make saving throws === | |||
While PCs continue to make saving throws as normal, monsters (and other NPCs) do not. What would normally be a spell's save difficulty (e.g. 10 + spell level + ability modifier, etc.) is now added to a player-rolled 1d20 to become '''magic check''', targeting a DC of 22 + the monster's normal save modifier (e.g. if the spell required a Fort save, and the monster's Fort modifier was +5, the DC of the magic check would be 27). If the magic check meets or exceeds the DC, it takes effect on the monster. Rolling a 1 on a magic check always means the spell fails, while rolling a natural 20 always succeeds. | |||
=== When players use spell resistance === | |||
When a PC has an SR rating, an attacker would normally make a caster level check top penetrate it. This roll is now made by the player as a '''spell resistance check''' rolling 1d20 + SR. The DC of this roll is equal to 22 + the attacking caster's level, plus any modifiers that normally apply to the attacker’s caster level check to overcome spell resistance (such as from the Spell Penetration feat). If the spell resistance check meets or exceeds the DC, the spell is resisted. Rolling a 1 on a magic check always means the spell gets thread, while rolling a natural 20 always resists. | |||
== Sneak Attacks and Ranged Weapons == | |||
Just a clarification to the standard rules on sneak attacks: | |||
* Sneak attacks ''can'' be made with ranged weapons, so long as the rogue is within "point-blank" range (30'). | |||
* Sneak attacks are allowed if the target is denied a Dex bonus, or if the rouge flanks the target. | |||
* You cannot normally flank a target with a ranged weapon. | |||
So, as practical matter, the only way you can typically sneak attack with a ranged weapon is by denying the target a Dex bonus (or by using Furtive Shot, below). Targets lose their Dex bonus to AC in any of the following situations: | |||
* Target is [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/conditions---final#TOC-Blinded|blinded]] | |||
* Target is [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/conditions---final#TOC-Cowering|cowering]] | |||
* Target is [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/conditions---final#TOC-Flat-Footed|flat-footed]] and does not have [[pfsrd:classes/basic-classes/rogue#TOC-Uncanny-Dodge-Ex-|Uncanny Dodge]] | |||
* Target is [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/conditions---final#TOC-Helpless|helpless]] | |||
* Target is [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/conditions---final#TOC-Stunned|stunned]] | |||
* Target is [[pfsrd:skills/climb|climbing]] | |||
* Target is running. | |||
* Attacker is [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/conditions---final#TOC-Invisible|invisible]] | |||
* Attacker successfully [[pfsrd:gamemastering---final/combat---final#TOC-Feint|feints]] against the target. | |||
* Attacker or ally uses [[pfsrd:feats/greater-feint-combat---final|Greater Feint]] against the target. | |||
== Touch Attack Effects == | |||
Not sure if this is actually a house rule or just a clarification. Certain powers require a successful touch attack. For such powers that have a limited number of uses per day (e.g. ''[[pfsrd-spell:p/produce-flame|produce flame]]'', ''[[pfsrd-spell:c/chill-touch|chill touch]]'', the touch power from the Evil domain, etc.) we allow these powers to activate on standard natural or unarmed attacks as well. (If the user is willing to expend a use of the power, why not?) Further, if the user has several of these effects available, they can activate as many of them as they like on the same attack (provided they expend a use of each power, of course). Such activations can also be stacked on top of "always on" effects of a touch attack (e.g. a lich's paralyzing touch, a spectre's energy drain, etc.). | |||
None of these effects can be used during attacks of opportunity. | |||
Note that this rule tends to be much more useful for monsters than it does for PCs. | |||
== Bloodline Attacks == | |||
Many of the sorcerer bloodlines bestow a standard action minor attack as bloodline power at first level, usable a limited number of times per day, but not really scaling well with level (apart from a very minor damage bump, usually). These powers are intended to give a first level sorcerer a bit more firepower, but they quickly become useless as the sorcerer levels, having better things to do with a standard action. This makes them significantly worse (and more boring) than some otherwise equivalent bloodline powers that do scale well with level. | |||
We change these powers to scale the ''timing'' of the minor attack with level. This still keeps them in the realm of small utility benefits, but turns these powers into something a rational sorcerer might actually have a reason to use at any level. These powers gain the following text: "At fifth level, this ability may be used as a move action. At tenth level, this ability may be used as a swift action. At fifteenth level, this ability may be used as an immediate action." | |||
This ruling effects at least the following powers (bloodline): acid ray (shaitan), acidic ray (abberant), electricity ray (djinni), elemental ray (elemental), fire ray (efreeti), frost ray (marid), heavenly fire (celestial), horrific visage (accursed), minute meteors (starsoul), wasting ray (dæmon) | |||
== Critical hits == | == Critical hits == | ||
Line 6: | Line 83: | ||
* You may roll for a critical hit, as per the standard rules. | * You may roll for a critical hit, as per the standard rules. | ||
* You may automatically just take max weapon damage. (If your critical multiplier is ×3, you deal | * You may automatically just take max weapon damage. (If your critical multiplier is ×3, you deal two times max weapon damage. At ×4, you deal three times max damage.) | ||
* You may roll for a critical hit, and on confirmation, draw a card from the Critical Hit deck, doing what the card says. If your critical multiplier is ×3, you add one to the multiplier mentioned on the card. With a ×4 multiplier, you add two. | |||
* You may roll for a critical hit, and on confirmation, draw a number of cards from the Critical Hit deck: ×2 multiplier draws one card, ×3 draws two, ×4 draws three. You then select ''one'' of the cards and do what it says exactly (i.e. no adjusting the multiplier). | |||
This is a bit of a trade off. All attacks deal three types of damage, and each choice deals with them differently: | This is a bit of a trade off. All attacks deal three types of damage, and each choice deals with them differently: | ||
Line 18: | Line 97: | ||
| '''Standard rules''' || colspan="2" | Make to-hit roll again. If you would hit, damage calculated a number of times equal to your critical multiplier (usually ×2) || Applied only once, even if critical succeeded. | | '''Standard rules''' || colspan="2" | Make to-hit roll again. If you would hit, damage calculated a number of times equal to your critical multiplier (usually ×2) || Applied only once, even if critical succeeded. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''House rule''' || No additional roll needed. Damage roll treated as if highest number came up on each die. If | | '''House rule''' || colspan="2" | ''No additional roll needed''. Damage roll treated as if highest number came up on each die. If multiplier is ×3, multiply the result by 2. If multiplier is ×4 multiply the result by 3. || Applied only once | ||
|} | |} | ||
To use abilities that trigger off of critical hits (such as critical feats), you ''must'' make the confirmation roll to determine if they take effect; however, you can still elect (prior to rolling) either damage option. For example, if someone with the Bleeding Critical feat rolled within their critical range, they could take the max damage, then roll a confirmation to see if the bleeding crit triggers, or they could roll the confirmation and, if successful, roll extra damage and the bleeding crit triggers. | |||
In most cases, the house rule will result in a lower ''average'' damage, but is reliable (i.e. you don't need to make the confirming "attack" roll). Some examples, always assuming a critical actually happens: | In most cases, the house rule will result in a lower ''average'' damage, but is reliable (i.e. you don't need to make the confirming "attack" roll). Some examples, always assuming a critical actually happens: | ||
Line 33: | Line 114: | ||
| '''Lostwhite w/ +1 greatsword''' || 2d6 || +11 || || ×2 || 2+11=<br/>13 || 7+11=<br/>18 || 12+11=<br/>23 || 2(1+11)=<br/>24 || 2(7+11)=<br/>36 || 2(12+11)=<br/>46 || colspan="3" | 12+11=<br/>23 | | '''Lostwhite w/ +1 greatsword''' || 2d6 || +11 || || ×2 || 2+11=<br/>13 || 7+11=<br/>18 || 12+11=<br/>23 || 2(1+11)=<br/>24 || 2(7+11)=<br/>36 || 2(12+11)=<br/>46 || colspan="3" | 12+11=<br/>23 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''Lostwhite w/ +1 battleaxe''' || 1d8 || +7 || || '''×3''' || 1+7=<br/>8 || 4.5+7=<br/>11.5 || 8+7=<br/>15 || 3(1+7)=<br/>24 || 3(4.5+7)=<br/>34.5 || 3(8+7)=<br/>45 || colspan="3" | | | '''Lostwhite w/ +1 battleaxe''' || 1d8 || +7 || || '''×3''' || 1+7=<br/>8 || 4.5+7=<br/>11.5 || 8+7=<br/>15 || 3(1+7)=<br/>24 || 3(4.5+7)=<br/>34.5 || 3(8+7)=<br/>45 || colspan="3" | 2(8+7)=<br/>30 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''Caralaria w/ fist and vital strike''' || 1d10 || +6 || +1d10 || ×2 || 1+6+1=<br/>8 || 5.5+6+5.5=<br/>16 || 10+6+10=<br/>26 || 2(1+6)+1=<br/>15 || 2(5.5+6)+5.5=<br/>28.5 || 2(10+6)+10=<br/>42 || 10+6+1=<br/>17 || 10+6+5.5=<br/>21.5 || 10+6+10=<br/>26 | | '''Caralaria w/ fist and vital strike''' || 1d10 || +6 || +1d10 || ×2 || 1+6+1=<br/>8 || 5.5+6+5.5=<br/>16 || 10+6+10=<br/>26 || 2(1+6)+1=<br/>15 || 2(5.5+6)+5.5=<br/>28.5 || 2(10+6)+10=<br/>42 || 10+6+1=<br/>17 || 10+6+5.5=<br/>21.5 || 10+6+10=<br/>26 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''Scoffney w/ +1 rifle''' || | | '''Scoffney w/ +1 rifle''' || 1d10 || +1 || || '''×4''' || 1+1=<br/>2 || 5.5+1=<br/>6.5 || 10+1=<br/>11 || 4(1+1)=<br/>8 || 4(5.5+1)=<br/>26 || 4(10+1)=<br/>44 || colspan="3" | 3(10+1)=<br/>33 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''Scoffney w/ +1 rifle and sneak attack''' || | | '''Scoffney w/ +1 rifle and sneak attack''' || 1d10 || +1 || +3d6 || '''×4''' || 1+1+3=<br/>5 || 5.5+1+3(3.5)=<br/>17 || 10+1+3(6)=<br/>29 || 4(1+1)+3=<br/>11 || 4(5.5+1)+3(3.5)=<br/>36.5 || 4(10+1)+3(6)=<br/>62 || 3(10+1)+3=<br/>36 || 3(10+1)+3(3.5)=<br/>43.5 || 3(10+1)+3(6)=<br/>51 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''Oreni's ''scorching ray''''' || 4d6 || || || ×2 || 4(1)=<br/>4 || 4(3.5)=<br/>14 || 4(6)=<br/>24 || 2(4(1))=<br/>8 || 2(4(3.5))=<br/>28 || 2(4(6))=<br/>48 || colspan="3" | 4(6)=<br/>24 | | '''Oreni's ''scorching ray''''' || 4d6 || || || ×2 || 4(1)=<br/>4 || 4(3.5)=<br/>14 || 4(6)=<br/>24 || 2(4(1))=<br/>8 || 2(4(3.5))=<br/>28 || 2(4(6))=<br/>48 || colspan="3" | 4(6)=<br/>24 | ||
Line 46: | Line 127: | ||
The moral of all this is that if you have a decent chance to hit, you will likely do more damage using the standard rules, but if you need a good roll to hit, you are better off with the house rule. Also, the larger your bonus damage is, the more advantage you will get from using the standard rule. | The moral of all this is that if you have a decent chance to hit, you will likely do more damage using the standard rules, but if you need a good roll to hit, you are better off with the house rule. Also, the larger your bonus damage is, the more advantage you will get from using the standard rule. | ||
== | == Feats and Such == | ||
=== Reach Spell === | |||
''Warning: this house rule is broken (you can tell because it is hard to imagine any caster that wouldn't take this feat). It also changes magic a bit (particularly for clerics and other healers). We know. We don't care. It's fun.'' | |||
This one started as a mistake, but was active for long enough to make us keep it. Reach Spell is no longer a metamagic feat. It is a standard feat that lets the caster cast any touch spell as a ranged touch attack if within "point blank" range (30'). | |||
=== Intensified Spell === | |||
Since, as written, intensified spell applies to such a small number of spells, we allow it to extend the level caps for certain spells beyond just damage dice. It now explicitly applies to spells that generate a level capped number of items per casting, including ''magic missile'', ''scorching ray'' and ''call lightning''. | |||
It also applies to spells with damage formulae such as "2d8 + caster level (max ''x'')", increasing ''x'' by five (i.e. most cure spells, ''produce flame'', ''fire shield'', etc.). This change is not all that useful in most cases (e.g. healing spells), as often you are better off casting a higher level spell instead of adding paying the one level metagmagic penalty. Might be worth it for druids casting heals or when using a metamagic rod. This feat still does not apply to non-damage formulae of this form (e.g. ''ray of enfeeblement''). | |||
== | === Vital Strike === | ||
From the look of the errata, looks like we read this one wrong as well, but we're keeping it too. We allow any attack to be declared (post attack roll) as a vital strike, but only once per round. | |||
=== Arcane Strike === | |||
Alchemists count as "arcane casters" for the purposes of qualifying for this feat. This may or may not be "official"; depends on who you ask. (Hero Lab does it this way, for example). | |||
=== Arterial Strike === | |||
This is a new feat, adapted from (but a bit more flexible than) the feat of the same name in ''Complete Warrior''. | |||
'''Prerequisite''': Sneak attack ability, base attack bonus +4.<br/> | |||
'''Benefit''': If you hit with a sneak attack, you may choose to forgo one or more +1d6 of extra sneak attack damage to deliver a wound that won't stop bleeding. For each die forgone, the target takes 1 [http://www.d20pfsrd.com/gamemastering/conditions#TOC-Bleed bleed]. Bleed from multiple arterial strikes stacks with each other, but not with other bleed effects that deal damage. | |||
== Close Shot (Combat) == | === Close Shot (Combat) === | ||
This is a new feat, which extends "point blank" range. | This is a new feat, which extends "point blank" range. | ||
'''Prerequisite''': base attack bonus +3. | '''Prerequisite''': base attack bonus +3.<br/> | ||
'''Benefit''': Any effect which specifically only works within "point blank" range may be used from an additional 30' away. That is, "point blank" range becomes 60'. Situations that benefit from this feat include: | '''Benefit''': Any effect which specifically only works within "point blank" range may be used from an additional 30' away. That is, "point blank" range becomes 60'. Situations that benefit from this feat include: | ||
* Using [ | * Using [[pfsrd:feats/point-blank-shot-combat---final|Point Blank Shot]]. | ||
* Sneak attacking with ranged weapons. | * Sneak attacking with ranged weapons. | ||
* Using the Reach Spell feat (see above). | * Using the Reach Spell feat (see above). | ||
* Casting touch spells from wands (see | * Casting touch spells from wands (see below). | ||
* The Furtive Shot rogue talent (see below). | |||
'''Normal''': Point blank range is normally 30'. | '''Normal''': Point blank range is normally 30'. | ||
== | === Furtive Shot === | ||
This is a new [[pfsrd:classes/basic-classes/rogue#TOC-Rogue-Talents|rogue talent]]: | |||
''Furtive Shot ([[pfsrd:basics-ability-scores/glossary---final#TOC-Extraordinary-Abilities-Ex-|Ex]])'': If within point-blank range of a target that is flanked by two or more of your allies, you may sneak attack that target with a ranged weapon. | |||
== Magical Items == | |||
=== Pearl of Power === | |||
Spontaneous casters can use a ''[[pfsrd:magic-items/wondrous-items#TOC-Pearl-of-Power|pearl of power]]'' to restore a spell slot, with one restriction: that slot can only be used to cast a specific spell that the user has already cast that day (specified when the perl is used). Also, anyone using a pearl must spend a full action to do so. | |||
=== Wands === | |||
We treat wands as if they all have the Reach Spell feat (see above). That is, if they cast a touch spell, they can do so as a ranged touch attack from 30 feet away. |
Latest revision as of 18:59, 2 May 2014
House rules for the Dissolution campaign.
Basic Conversion
Since Ptolus is a 3.5 production, some basic conversion to Pathfinder was required.
Classes
We add some unofficial classes:
- Elemental Druid - a variation of the druid class, based on the four elements instead of animals and nature.
- Arcane Hierophant - a divine/arcane prestige class lifted and mutated from 3.5.
- Spellsword - a gish prestige class lifted and (severely) mutated from 3.5. After using it for a while, we ditched it.
Experience
Progression
This is a really casual game that doesn't meet very often. So, we are using the "fast" experience table.
Ding!
Along the same lines: we follow a more video game style of advancement. As soon as you gain enough XP to level, you immediately do so. In addition, you regain all hit points and gain and benefits as if having taken a full rest (spells refresh, etc.). There are campaigns where things like training and safe zones and such matter; this isn't one of them.
Players Roll Most Dice
In order to get the players more involved when it is the monster's turn, and to distribute (and often parallelise!) monster's actions, players roll most dice. Nothing changes when the PCs act; they roll just the same as always. When a monster attacks a PC, however, instead of the monster rolling an attack, the PC rolls defense. This works as follows (note, the number 22 looks a bit odd in the following formulas, but guarantees that the probability of being hit and so on remains unchanged):
When monsters attack
The PC getting attacked makes a defense check, rolling 1d20 + applicable AC against a DC of 22 + the attack modifier of the incoming attack. If the player meets or exceeds this DC, the attack misses. As with attack rolls, on the defense check a 1 always fails (meaning, you get hit) and a 20 always succeeds (meaning you defend, so the attack doesn't hurt you).
On a roll of a natural 1, the attacking monster scores a threat (a possible critical hit). Make another defense check; if it again fails to avoid the attack, the opponent has scored a critical hit. If the monster has a greater critical range than usual, they threaten with a corresponding low defense check. For example, if the monster would threaten when rolling an 18-20 under normal rules, it would threaten if the defense check came up 1-3.
When monsters need to make saving throws
While PCs continue to make saving throws as normal, monsters (and other NPCs) do not. What would normally be a spell's save difficulty (e.g. 10 + spell level + ability modifier, etc.) is now added to a player-rolled 1d20 to become magic check, targeting a DC of 22 + the monster's normal save modifier (e.g. if the spell required a Fort save, and the monster's Fort modifier was +5, the DC of the magic check would be 27). If the magic check meets or exceeds the DC, it takes effect on the monster. Rolling a 1 on a magic check always means the spell fails, while rolling a natural 20 always succeeds.
When players use spell resistance
When a PC has an SR rating, an attacker would normally make a caster level check top penetrate it. This roll is now made by the player as a spell resistance check rolling 1d20 + SR. The DC of this roll is equal to 22 + the attacking caster's level, plus any modifiers that normally apply to the attacker’s caster level check to overcome spell resistance (such as from the Spell Penetration feat). If the spell resistance check meets or exceeds the DC, the spell is resisted. Rolling a 1 on a magic check always means the spell gets thread, while rolling a natural 20 always resists.
Sneak Attacks and Ranged Weapons
Just a clarification to the standard rules on sneak attacks:
- Sneak attacks can be made with ranged weapons, so long as the rogue is within "point-blank" range (30').
- Sneak attacks are allowed if the target is denied a Dex bonus, or if the rouge flanks the target.
- You cannot normally flank a target with a ranged weapon.
So, as practical matter, the only way you can typically sneak attack with a ranged weapon is by denying the target a Dex bonus (or by using Furtive Shot, below). Targets lose their Dex bonus to AC in any of the following situations:
- Target is blinded
- Target is cowering
- Target is flat-footed and does not have Uncanny Dodge
- Target is helpless
- Target is stunned
- Target is climbing
- Target is running.
- Attacker is invisible
- Attacker successfully feints against the target.
- Attacker or ally uses Greater Feint against the target.
Touch Attack Effects
Not sure if this is actually a house rule or just a clarification. Certain powers require a successful touch attack. For such powers that have a limited number of uses per day (e.g. produce flame, chill touch, the touch power from the Evil domain, etc.) we allow these powers to activate on standard natural or unarmed attacks as well. (If the user is willing to expend a use of the power, why not?) Further, if the user has several of these effects available, they can activate as many of them as they like on the same attack (provided they expend a use of each power, of course). Such activations can also be stacked on top of "always on" effects of a touch attack (e.g. a lich's paralyzing touch, a spectre's energy drain, etc.).
None of these effects can be used during attacks of opportunity.
Note that this rule tends to be much more useful for monsters than it does for PCs.
Bloodline Attacks
Many of the sorcerer bloodlines bestow a standard action minor attack as bloodline power at first level, usable a limited number of times per day, but not really scaling well with level (apart from a very minor damage bump, usually). These powers are intended to give a first level sorcerer a bit more firepower, but they quickly become useless as the sorcerer levels, having better things to do with a standard action. This makes them significantly worse (and more boring) than some otherwise equivalent bloodline powers that do scale well with level.
We change these powers to scale the timing of the minor attack with level. This still keeps them in the realm of small utility benefits, but turns these powers into something a rational sorcerer might actually have a reason to use at any level. These powers gain the following text: "At fifth level, this ability may be used as a move action. At tenth level, this ability may be used as a swift action. At fifteenth level, this ability may be used as an immediate action."
This ruling effects at least the following powers (bloodline): acid ray (shaitan), acidic ray (abberant), electricity ray (djinni), elemental ray (elemental), fire ray (efreeti), frost ray (marid), heavenly fire (celestial), horrific visage (accursed), minute meteors (starsoul), wasting ray (dæmon)
Critical hits
When you roll within your critical range, you have a choice:
- You may roll for a critical hit, as per the standard rules.
- You may automatically just take max weapon damage. (If your critical multiplier is ×3, you deal two times max weapon damage. At ×4, you deal three times max damage.)
- You may roll for a critical hit, and on confirmation, draw a card from the Critical Hit deck, doing what the card says. If your critical multiplier is ×3, you add one to the multiplier mentioned on the card. With a ×4 multiplier, you add two.
- You may roll for a critical hit, and on confirmation, draw a number of cards from the Critical Hit deck: ×2 multiplier draws one card, ×3 draws two, ×4 draws three. You then select one of the cards and do what it says exactly (i.e. no adjusting the multiplier).
This is a bit of a trade off. All attacks deal three types of damage, and each choice deals with them differently:
Type | Weapon damage | Bonus damage | Ancillary damage |
Description | the base dice damage of the weapon | fixed damage from strength, magical plusses, etc. | sneak attack, vital strike, added energy damage, etc. |
Standard rules | Make to-hit roll again. If you would hit, damage calculated a number of times equal to your critical multiplier (usually ×2) | Applied only once, even if critical succeeded. | |
House rule | No additional roll needed. Damage roll treated as if highest number came up on each die. If multiplier is ×3, multiply the result by 2. If multiplier is ×4 multiply the result by 3. | Applied only once |
To use abilities that trigger off of critical hits (such as critical feats), you must make the confirmation roll to determine if they take effect; however, you can still elect (prior to rolling) either damage option. For example, if someone with the Bleeding Critical feat rolled within their critical range, they could take the max damage, then roll a confirmation to see if the bleeding crit triggers, or they could roll the confirmation and, if successful, roll extra damage and the bleeding crit triggers.
In most cases, the house rule will result in a lower average damage, but is reliable (i.e. you don't need to make the confirming "attack" roll). Some examples, always assuming a critical actually happens:
Damage Roll | No crit | Standard crit (if achieved) | House rule | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Situation | Weapon | Bonus | Ancillary | Crit range | Min | Average | Max | Min | Average | Max | Min | Average | Max |
Lostwhite w/ +1 flaming flail | 1d8 | +9 | +1d6 fire | ×2 | 1+9+1= 11 |
4.5+9+3.5= 17 |
8+9+6= 23 |
2(1+9)+1= 21 |
2(4.5+9)+3.5= 30.5 |
2(8+9)+6= 40 |
8+9+1= 18 |
8+9+3.5= 20.5 |
8+9+6= 23 |
Lostwhite w/ +1 greatsword | 2d6 | +11 | ×2 | 2+11= 13 |
7+11= 18 |
12+11= 23 |
2(1+11)= 24 |
2(7+11)= 36 |
2(12+11)= 46 |
12+11= 23 | |||
Lostwhite w/ +1 battleaxe | 1d8 | +7 | ×3 | 1+7= 8 |
4.5+7= 11.5 |
8+7= 15 |
3(1+7)= 24 |
3(4.5+7)= 34.5 |
3(8+7)= 45 |
2(8+7)= 30 | |||
Caralaria w/ fist and vital strike | 1d10 | +6 | +1d10 | ×2 | 1+6+1= 8 |
5.5+6+5.5= 16 |
10+6+10= 26 |
2(1+6)+1= 15 |
2(5.5+6)+5.5= 28.5 |
2(10+6)+10= 42 |
10+6+1= 17 |
10+6+5.5= 21.5 |
10+6+10= 26 |
Scoffney w/ +1 rifle | 1d10 | +1 | ×4 | 1+1= 2 |
5.5+1= 6.5 |
10+1= 11 |
4(1+1)= 8 |
4(5.5+1)= 26 |
4(10+1)= 44 |
3(10+1)= 33 | |||
Scoffney w/ +1 rifle and sneak attack | 1d10 | +1 | +3d6 | ×4 | 1+1+3= 5 |
5.5+1+3(3.5)= 17 |
10+1+3(6)= 29 |
4(1+1)+3= 11 |
4(5.5+1)+3(3.5)= 36.5 |
4(10+1)+3(6)= 62 |
3(10+1)+3= 36 |
3(10+1)+3(3.5)= 43.5 |
3(10+1)+3(6)= 51 |
Oreni's scorching ray | 4d6 | ×2 | 4(1)= 4 |
4(3.5)= 14 |
4(6)= 24 |
2(4(1))= 8 |
2(4(3.5))= 28 |
2(4(6))= 48 |
4(6)= 24 |
The moral of all this is that if you have a decent chance to hit, you will likely do more damage using the standard rules, but if you need a good roll to hit, you are better off with the house rule. Also, the larger your bonus damage is, the more advantage you will get from using the standard rule.
Feats and Such
Reach Spell
Warning: this house rule is broken (you can tell because it is hard to imagine any caster that wouldn't take this feat). It also changes magic a bit (particularly for clerics and other healers). We know. We don't care. It's fun.
This one started as a mistake, but was active for long enough to make us keep it. Reach Spell is no longer a metamagic feat. It is a standard feat that lets the caster cast any touch spell as a ranged touch attack if within "point blank" range (30').
Intensified Spell
Since, as written, intensified spell applies to such a small number of spells, we allow it to extend the level caps for certain spells beyond just damage dice. It now explicitly applies to spells that generate a level capped number of items per casting, including magic missile, scorching ray and call lightning.
It also applies to spells with damage formulae such as "2d8 + caster level (max x)", increasing x by five (i.e. most cure spells, produce flame, fire shield, etc.). This change is not all that useful in most cases (e.g. healing spells), as often you are better off casting a higher level spell instead of adding paying the one level metagmagic penalty. Might be worth it for druids casting heals or when using a metamagic rod. This feat still does not apply to non-damage formulae of this form (e.g. ray of enfeeblement).
Vital Strike
From the look of the errata, looks like we read this one wrong as well, but we're keeping it too. We allow any attack to be declared (post attack roll) as a vital strike, but only once per round.
Arcane Strike
Alchemists count as "arcane casters" for the purposes of qualifying for this feat. This may or may not be "official"; depends on who you ask. (Hero Lab does it this way, for example).
Arterial Strike
This is a new feat, adapted from (but a bit more flexible than) the feat of the same name in Complete Warrior.
Prerequisite: Sneak attack ability, base attack bonus +4.
Benefit: If you hit with a sneak attack, you may choose to forgo one or more +1d6 of extra sneak attack damage to deliver a wound that won't stop bleeding. For each die forgone, the target takes 1 bleed. Bleed from multiple arterial strikes stacks with each other, but not with other bleed effects that deal damage.
Close Shot (Combat)
This is a new feat, which extends "point blank" range.
Prerequisite: base attack bonus +3.
Benefit: Any effect which specifically only works within "point blank" range may be used from an additional 30' away. That is, "point blank" range becomes 60'. Situations that benefit from this feat include:
- Using Point Blank Shot.
- Sneak attacking with ranged weapons.
- Using the Reach Spell feat (see above).
- Casting touch spells from wands (see below).
- The Furtive Shot rogue talent (see below).
Normal: Point blank range is normally 30'.
Furtive Shot
This is a new rogue talent:
Furtive Shot (Ex): If within point-blank range of a target that is flanked by two or more of your allies, you may sneak attack that target with a ranged weapon.
Magical Items
Pearl of Power
Spontaneous casters can use a pearl of power to restore a spell slot, with one restriction: that slot can only be used to cast a specific spell that the user has already cast that day (specified when the perl is used). Also, anyone using a pearl must spend a full action to do so.
Wands
We treat wands as if they all have the Reach Spell feat (see above). That is, if they cast a touch spell, they can do so as a ranged touch attack from 30 feet away.